MenuEnglish

HomeArticlesPanic of 1873: Causes and Effects of the Railroad Crash

Panic of 1873: Causes and Effects of the Railroad Crash

A Rails and Rivals map with rail networks
Rails & Rivals, our game.

The Panic of 1873 began in the United States on September 18, 1873, when the Philadelphia banking house Jay Cooke and Company shut its doors after it could not sell enough bonds to cover the money it had advanced for building the Northern Pacific Railway. The failure set off a chain of bank runs and railroad bankruptcies that closed the New York Stock Exchange for ten days and pushed the country into years of unemployment and wage cuts.

Timeline: From the Railroad Boom to the 1877 Strike

Wood engraving of crowds in Wall Street outside the office of Jay Cooke and Company
Scenes in Wall Street during the panic, with the office of Jay Cooke and Company, a wood engraving from 1873. Image: Library of Congress, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Post-Civil War Railroad Boom

Railroads were the largest employer in the United States outside agriculture during the years after the Civil War.

Lithograph of people fleeing a burning city across a bridge at night
Chicago in Flames, a Currier and Ives lithograph of 1871 showing people fleeing across the Randolph Street Bridge. The Chicago fire of 1871 was one of the shocks the boom came through before the crash. Image: Currier and Ives, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Economic historians debate how much weight to give to several strains that were building at the same time. Before the crash, the railroad boom had already come through several earlier shocks: a gold-market panic in 1869 remembered as Black Friday, a fire that destroyed much of Chicago in 1871, a widespread epidemic of horse flu, and a fire that struck Boston the following year, in 1872. In 1873, the United States Congress passed the Coinage Act of 1873, which moved the country toward a gold standard and ended the government's practice of buying silver at a fixed statutory price. Germany went through a related process: after its victory in the Franco-Prussian War, Otto von Bismarck began demonetizing silver and put Germany on the gold standard, culminating in the introduction of the gold mark on July 9, 1873.

Jay Cooke and the Northern Pacific

Financial trouble struck Europe first. The Vienna Stock Exchange crashed in May 1873, and crashed again that September, and the shock sent European investors rushing to unload the American stocks and bonds they held, railroad bonds above all. That selling depressed prices on stocks and bonds and made it harder for American railroad firms to raise financing.

Jay Cooke and Company was a bank that Jay Cooke, an American financier, opened in Philadelphia on January 1, 1861, just months before the Civil War began. During the war, Cooke and Company sold hundreds of millions of dollars in Union government bonds, including the government's five-twenty bond issue, which paid six percent interest in gold, matured in twenty years, and was callable after five. Cooke sold the bonds through numerous agents drawn from banking, insurance and real estate, and his firm pioneered the use of telegraph messages to confirm sales, making it the country's first wire brokerage house.

Standing portrait photograph of Jay Cooke in a dark suit
Jay Cooke, photographed during the Civil War, when his firm sold Union government bonds. Photo: Wenderoth & Taylor, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

In 1870, the Northern Pacific Railroad made Cooke and Company its exclusive bond agent, and ground was broken for the line at Carlton, Minnesota, on February 15, 1870. The Northern Pacific was meant to become the country's second transcontinental railroad, after the first transcontinental railroad was completed in 1869. The Northern Pacific reached Fargo in Dakota Territory in 1872, and its tracks reached the Missouri River at Edwinton, soon renamed Bismarck, in June 1873. On July 14, 1873, Tacoma, Washington Territory, was chosen as the railroad's western terminus.

Cooke had difficulty marketing the Northern Pacific's bonds to investors. His firm wound up owning 75 percent of the railroad and overextended its own capital advancing money for construction. As this liability became public, investors began withdrawing their money from Cooke and Company, and on September 18, 1873, a run on the bank forced it to suspend operations. When the New York Stock Exchange heard the news, equities plummeted, touching off a chain reaction of bank runs and failures across the country, and the exchange itself closed for ten days starting September 20, 1873, the first closure in its history. Cooke's failure was soon followed by the collapse of other banking houses that had backed the railroads, including Henry Clews' firm and Fisk and Hatch.

Effects of the Panic of 1873

Factories began laying off workers as the country slipped into depression. The effects of the panic were felt quickly in New York, then more slowly in Chicago, Virginia City, Nevada, and San Francisco.

Wood engraving of a crowd pressing at the doors of a New York bank
The run on the Fourth National Bank at No. 20 Nassau Street, New York City, a wood engraving from 1873. Image: Library of Congress, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
EffectFigure
Railroads bankruptedBy one estimate, 89 of the country's 364 railroads
Unemployment nationally by 1876about 14 percent
Unemployment in New York Cityabout one in four workers, winter 1873 to 1874
US depressionlasted until the spring of 1879
1874 electionsDemocrats took the House majority, their first since before the war
1875 monetary lawSpecie Resumption Act, to back US currency with gold

The depression also shook the insurance business. Many US insurance companies went out of business as the panic created solvency problems for life insurers; the firms that survived shared one feature, they all marketed tontines.

Numbers that disagree

Sources give different figures for how long the slump lasted. In the United States, the National Bureau of Economic Research dates the contraction from October 1873 to March 1879. Broader measures of the related international Long Depression track the slump as continuing as late as 1899, depending on which metric is used. In Britain, commentators at the time described a continuous depression running from 1873 to as late as 1896, which some texts call the Great Depression of 1873 to 1896. In the United States itself, the whole episode was known as "the Great Depression" before the 1929 crash and the years that followed pushed economic collapse to a far larger scale and claimed the name instead.

From Panic to the 1877 Strike

The railroad industry had grown rapidly in the decades before 1873, driven partly by strong European interest in railroad bonds, and the failure of Jay Cooke and Co. triggered a crisis across that industry. In 1877, steep wage cuts led railroad workers to launch the protests and riots later called the Great Railroad Strike. The strike began in Martinsburg, West Virginia, after the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad cut workers' pay for the third time in a year. West Virginia Governor Henry M. Mathews sent the state militia, under Colonel Charles J. Faulkner, but it failed largely because the militia sympathized with the strikers, so Mathews called on President Rutherford B. Hayes for federal assistance, and Hayes dispatched federal troops. Labor trouble on the Northern Pacific did not end with the 1870s depression: in 1894, the US Army's 10th Cavalry Regiment was called in to protect Northern Pacific property during a separate strike by the railroad's workers.

Engraving of idle locomotives and a crowd of strikers on the tracks at a rail yard
Blockade of Engines at Martinsburg, West Virginia, where the 1877 strike began, from the cover of Harper's Weekly, August 11, 1877. Image: Harper's Weekly, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

What Happened to the Northern Pacific

Construction on the Northern Pacific resumed in a small way in 1877.

Illustration of a crowd around a man raising a maul to drive a rail spike
Driving the last spike on the Northern Pacific at Gold Creek, Montana, on September 8, 1883, with Ulysses S. Grant holding the spike maul and Henry Villard, then president of the Northern Pacific, at his left. Image: Unknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Tacoma, the Northern Pacific's chosen Pacific terminus, grew quickly once the railroad reached the area: the town had 1,098 residents in 1880 and 36,000 by 1889.

Henry Villard, a German-American journalist and financier, was elected president of the reorganized Northern Pacific board on September 15, 1881, after raising capital for western railroads in Europe, especially in the German Empire, from 1871 to 1873. Villard assembled a syndicate that the press called a "blind pool," made up of friends who loaned him $20 million without knowing his intentions. The crews building from east and west met near Independence Creek in western Montana on August 22, 1883, close to Gold Creek, where gold had first been discovered in Montana, connecting the line, though the ceremonial spike was not driven until September 8. On September 8, 1883, at Gold Creek, former President Ulysses S. Grant joined Villard and Henry C. Davis, who had helped drive the first spike, in driving the final "golden spike," which was the same spike used thirteen years earlier at the Carlton, Minnesota groundbreaking. The railroad was opened to traffic with festivities in September 1883. Villard suffered a nervous breakdown soon after the ceremony and left the Northern Pacific presidency in January 1884.

Jay Cooke met all his financial obligations by 1880, after an investment in the Horn Silver Mine in Utah made him wealthy again. He died in the Ogontz section of Cheltenham Township, Pennsylvania, now Elkins Park, on February 16, 1905.

FAQ

What caused the Panic of 1873?

The immediate cause of the Panic of 1873 was the failure of Jay Cooke and Company on September 18, 1873, after the bank could not sell enough Northern Pacific Railway bonds to cover the money it had advanced for construction. Economic historians also point to the Coinage Act of 1873's move toward a gold standard, Germany's demonetization of silver after the Franco-Prussian War, and the Chicago fire of 1871 and Boston fire of 1872 as strains that had already weakened the economy.

What were the effects of the Panic of 1873?

Unemployment reached about 14 percent nationally by 1876, about a quarter of New York City's workers were out of work over the winter of 1873 to 1874, and in 1877 railroad wage cuts triggered the Great Railroad Strike.

Which US president was in office during the Panic of 1873?

Ulysses S. Grant was president when the panic struck. His policy of contracting the money supply raised interest rates and made conditions worse for people in debt, and on April 22, 1874, he vetoed a Senate bill that would have expanded the paper currency in circulation by $100,000,000.

How does the Panic of 1873 compare to the Great Depression?

In the United States, the slump that followed the Panic of 1873 was called the "Great Depression" before the stock market crash of 1929 and the harder years that followed redefined the term on a much larger scale. The National Bureau of Economic Research dates the US contraction from October 1873 to March 1879, while broader measures of the related international Long Depression track effects running as late as 1899.

When did the Panic of 1873 happen?

Jay Cooke and Company failed on September 18, 1873, and the New York Stock Exchange closed for ten days starting September 20, 1873. The resulting depression in the United States lasted until the spring of 1879.

Share certificates offered when issuing a bond in Rails and Rivals
Rails & Rivals, our game.

Rails & Rivals, our game on Steam, is a turn-based railroad strategy board game for 2 to 6 players: each player runs a rail company, lays track across a hex map and carries goods between cities, and the wealthiest company wins. The how to play page has the rules.

Keep reading

Sources