Santa Fe Railroad History: Royal Gorge War to Harvey Houses

The Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway, usually called the Santa Fe or AT&SF, was chartered in February 1859 to connect Atchison and Topeka, Kansas, with Santa Fe, New Mexico, and it grew into one of the largest Class 1 railroads in the United States before merging into the Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway and ending independent operations on December 31, 1996. Along the way it built west to Chicago by 1887, fought the Denver and Rio Grande for a narrow Colorado canyon, and put Fred Harvey's dining rooms and hotels along its tracks.
Building West: Atchison to the Pacific
As the line was built west, many of its tracks were laid directly over the wagon ruts of the old Santa Fe Trail. Track work carried the line to the Kansas-Colorado state line by 1873, and the railroad rolled into Pueblo, Colorado, three years later, in 1876. When the line was extended to Newton, Kansas, in 1871, it became a major cattle shipper at the end of the Texas cattle drive trails. To create demand for its own services, the railroad set up real estate offices and sold off farmland from the land grants Congress had awarded it for laying track.

In 1880, a branch line from Lamy, New Mexico, carried the Santa Fe railroad the 20 miles to its namesake city. That same year, the company reached Arizona and California by taking control of the western portion of the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad. It reached Chicago in 1887 by acquiring the Chicago and St. Louis Railway, and by that year its mainline ran unbroken from Chicago to Los Angeles under one corporation.
Expansion continued for decades. The railroad started what became the Panhandle and Santa Fe Railway into Texas in 1886 and acquired the Gulf, Colorado and Santa Fe Railway in 1887. It reached San Francisco in 1891 by buying the San Francisco and San Joaquin Valley Railway, acquired the Southern California Railway in 1906, added a Phoenix branch through the Santa Fe, Prescott and Phoenix Railway in 1911, and acquired the Kansas City, Mexico and Orient Railway in 1928. The railroad completed a Grand Canyon branch in 1901. Behind all this building stood repair shops: Topeka's shops were relocated in 1878 and expanded in 1902, Albuquerque's shops opened in 1880 and were expanded in 1925, a shop opened at San Bernardino, California, in 1886, and a fourth major shop went up at Cleburne, Texas, in 1899. The company's first general office building had gone up in Topeka back in 1869.
The Royal Gorge War, 1878 to 1880
The Royal Gorge War grew out of the Leadville silver boom, as miners poured into Colorado's upper Arkansas River valley chasing carbonate ores rich in lead and silver. The Royal Gorge itself was the obstacle: at its narrowest point, sheer rock walls on both sides plunge into the river, leaving room for only one railroad line. On April 19, 1878, a construction crew working for the Santa Fe's proxy, the Canon City and San Juan Railroad, began grading for a line just west of Canon City at the mouth of the gorge.

A federal circuit court ruled for the Santa Fe on August 23, 1878, allowing it to build through the first 20 miles of the 50 mile canyon, with the Rio Grande given only the right to lay track that did not interfere. A lease of the Rio Grande's line to the Santa Fe took effect December 13, 1878, and the Santa Fe soon raised freight rates to favor its own routes. By March 1879 the Rio Grande was trying to break that lease, and on April 21, 1879, the United States Supreme Court reversed course, granting the Rio Grande the primary right to build through the gorge because Congress had already given it prior right to the full 50 miles back in 1872.
Some one-sided accounts from the time claimed men were killed by the opposing company's hired guns, but historians have found no solid evidence that any fatalities actually occurred. In the fall of 1879, Jay Gould loaned the Rio Grande $400,000 and bought a 50 percent interest in the company, announcing plans for a competing line from St. Louis to Pueblo.
The companies finally settled out of court in what was called the Treaty of Boston, signed in early 1880, which ended the litigation and handed the Rio Grande back its railroad. Under the settlement the Rio Grande paid the Santa Fe $1.8 million, a figure that included a $400,000 bonus over the Santa Fe's actual construction costs. Inside the gorge, the Hanging Bridge, built in 1879, carried the line through the canyon on a 175 foot plate girder suspended under A-frame girders, and it was strengthened over the years to stay in service.
Raton Pass and the 1908 Belen Cutoff
Raton Pass, on the Colorado-New Mexico border, was the Santa Fe's primary route through the mountains in the late 19th century and, along with the Royal Gorge, was one of the focal points of the 1878-79 railroad war with the Denver and Rio Grande. In 1908 the Santa Fe opened the Belen Cutoff, an alternate route whose gradients did not exceed 1.25 percent, giving the railroad a far gentler path for freight traffic than the original line over Raton Pass.

Fred Harvey and the Harvey Houses
Fred Harvey emigrated to the United States from England as a 17 year old, arriving in 1853, and he was working as a freight agent for the Chicago, Burlington and Quincy Railroad when he began opening railroad eating houses in the 1870s. Harvey's ties to the Santa Fe date to 1876, when he worked out an informal, spoken arrangement with Charles Morse, someone he already knew, and that handshake deal put Harvey in charge of a small, 20-seat lunch counter inside the railroad's Topeka depot beginning that January. Harvey also opened an early hotel and dining house along the AT&SF tracks at Florence, Kansas, and a second Harvey House followed at Lakin, Kansas, in 1879, after which the chain spread quickly across the Santa Fe system.

By the late 1880s there was a Fred Harvey dining facility roughly every 100 miles along the AT&SF, matching the interval at which trains needed to refuel and take on water. To keep every Harvey House stocked, the railroad shipped fresh meat and produce at no cost using its own fleet of refrigerated cars, branded the Santa Fe Refrigerator Despatch, pulling in ingredients from all over the nation. A system of signals let the dining room staff prepare to feed an entire train within thirty minutes of its arrival. Harvey's houses became known for small touches of order: pies were cut into fourths rather than the industry standard sixths, and waitresses used a cup code, placing cups on their saucers in a particular way to signal a diner's drink order without a word being exchanged. Harvey mandated that every man in the dining room wear a coat.
When Fred Harvey died in 1901, his empire included 45 restaurants and 20 dining cars spread across 12 states, and at its peak the Fred Harvey Company operated more than 80 houses across the American West. The Grand Canyon became the Santa Fe's main tourist destination and a major focus of the Harvey Company's work, especially after the canyon became a national park in 1919; Bright Angel Lodge there was completed in 1935, during the Great Depression.
Some historians trace the "blue plate special" (an affordable fixed meal plated on patterned blue china) back to the Harvey Houses, pointing to a Harvey menu from 1892 that used the idea roughly three decades before the phrase caught on nationwide. When World War II filled troop trains with soldiers crossing the country, Harvey Houses reopened to feed them along the route, and by 1968, when the Fred Harvey Company was sold to Amfac Inc., later renamed Xanterra Parks and Resorts in 2002, it had grown into the sixth largest food retailer in the United States.
The Harvey Girls, from 1883
In 1883, Fred Harvey replaced his all male waiting staff with women, a workforce that became known as the Harvey Girls. Newspaper advertisements recruiting them sought waitresses who were white and young, between 18 and 30 years old, of good character, attractive and intelligent, to work specifically in Harvey Eating Houses along the Santa Fe Railroad in the West. Women who took the job signed on for terms of six, nine or twelve months, earning pay plus free lodging and meals, tips from customers, and passes to ride the Santa Fe line at no charge. They wore a standard uniform of a black or white starched skirt and a high collared blouse with a bib and apron.

The Harvey Girls were said to have helped civilize the American Southwest, a legend that found its way into The Harvey Girls, a 1942 novel by Samuel Hopkins Adams, and into the 1946 MGM musical film of the same name, directed by George Sidney and starring Judy Garland, which was inspired by the novel. The song "On the Atchison, Topeka and the Santa Fe," written by Harry Warren and Johnny Mercer for that film, was sung by Judy Garland with support from cast members including Ben Carter, Marjorie Main, Virginia O'Brien and Ray Bolger, and it went on to win the 1946 Academy Award for Best Original Song.
Harvey Houses: Still Standing and Lost
Many Harvey Houses survived as hotels or museums, while others were lost entirely. Their outcomes, as the historical record gives them, varied widely from building to building.

| Harvey House | Status |
|---|---|
| El Tovar (Grand Canyon) | Opened in 1905 and continued operating as a hotel. |
| La Fonda (Santa Fe, New Mexico) | Continued operating, under different owners. |
| La Posada (Winslow, Arizona) | Closed in 1957; later restored and reopened as a historic hotel. |
| The Castaneda (Las Vegas, New Mexico) | Closed in 1948; restored and reopened in 2019. |
| Casa del Desierto (Barstow, California) | Closed in 1959; refurbished in 1999 and reopened as two museums and city offices. |
| Belen Harvey House (Belen, New Mexico) | Closed in 1939; became a Harvey House Museum. |
| Florence Harvey House (Florence, Kansas) | Built in 1876; became a Harvey House Museum. |
| El Garces (Needles, California) | Closed in 1958; restored in 2014. |
| Slaton Harvey House (Slaton, Texas) | Opened in 1912; restaurant closed in 1942; later reopened as an event center and bed and breakfast. |
| Los Angeles Union Station Harvey House | Closed in 1967; reopened in 2018 as a bar. |
| El Navajo (Gallup, New Mexico) | Closed and demolished in 1957. |
| The Alvarado (Albuquerque, New Mexico) | Closed in 1970 and demolished. |
| Havasu House (Seligman, Arizona) | Closed in 1955; demolished in 2008. |
| The Escalante (Ash Fork, Arizona) | Shut its doors in 1948; torn down roughly two decades later. |
The Super Chief and the Warbonnet Livery
Santa Fe's first diesel electric passenger locomotives entered service on the Super Chief on May 12, 1936, pulling air conditioned heavyweight Pullman cars and tying the train to the Pullman Company. The red, yellow and silver Warbonnet paint scheme, devised by Leland Knickerbocker of General Motors' Art and Color Section, entered regular service on June 15, 1937. The Santa Fe later added dome cars to the Super Chief in 1951, billed as the only dome cars running between Chicago and Los Angeles, and introduced double decker Hi-Level cars on the El Capitan in 1954.

On May 1, 1971, the Santa Fe ceased operating its own passenger trains and conveyed them to the newly formed Amtrak, which retained the Super Chief name.
The End of Independent Operation, 1983 to 1996
A merger between the Santa Fe and the Southern Pacific, announced in 1983 as the Southern Pacific Santa Fe Railroad, would have placed both companies' rail and non-rail assets under one holding company. So sure were the two companies that regulators would sign off that crews had already started giving locomotives and non-revenue cars a shared new paint job before the Interstate Commerce Commission rejected the deal, ruling that it would leave too many duplicate routes in place.

The Santa Fe and the Burlington Northern Railroad combined on September 22, 1995, taking on a new name together: the Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway, or BNSF for short. The Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe officially ceased independent operations on December 31, 1996. As a company the Santa Fe no longer exists; its lines now run as part of BNSF.
A Pioneer Beyond the Rails
The Santa Fe was a pioneer in intermodal freight transport, and at various times it also operated an airline, the short-lived Santa Fe Skyway, and a fleet of Santa Fe Railroad tugboats. Its bus line extended passenger transportation to towns the rails never reached, and ferryboats on San Francisco Bay let travelers complete their westward journeys all the way to the Pacific Ocean, a service the railroad discontinued in 1933 because of the Great Depression.

Rails & Rivals, our game on Steam, is a turn-based railroad strategy board game for 2 to 6 players: each player runs a rail company, lays track across a hex map and carries goods between cities, and the wealthiest company wins. The how to play page has the rules.
Keep reading
Sources
- Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway (Wikipedia)
- Super Chief (Wikipedia)
- Royal Gorge War (Wikipedia)
- Raton Pass (Wikipedia)
- On the Atchison, Topeka and the Santa Fe (Wikipedia)
- The Harvey Girls (1946 film) (Wikipedia)
- Fred Harvey (entrepreneur) (Wikipedia)
- Fred Harvey Company (Wikipedia)
- Fred Harvey (Kansas Historical Society (Kansapedia))
- Conducting Railroad History (Texas Historical Commission)
- Harvey Girls (Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture) (Oklahoma Historical Society)
- Harvey House (Wikipedia)
- Royal Gorge Route Railroad (Wikipedia)
- Cyrus K. Holliday (Wikipedia)