MenuEnglish

HomeArticlesPennsylvania Railroad History: Rise, Rivals and Penn Station

Pennsylvania Railroad History: Rise, Rivals and Penn Station

Old locomotive on display at Horseshoe Curve on the Pennsylvania Railroad route.
Locomotive number 7048 on display at Horseshoe Curve, Pennsylvania Railroad route, photographed in 2017. Image: Patrick Kinney, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Pennsylvania Railroad was a Class I railroad in the United States, headquartered in Philadelphia, that by 1882 had grown into the largest corporation in the world. By 1968 it had merged into the Penn Central Transportation Company, with most of its track eventually passing first to Conrail and later to Norfolk Southern.

Founding the Pennsylvania Railroad

Philadelphia business interests watched with alarm as the Erie Canal, opened in 1825, and the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal, whose construction began in 1828, offered new routes that could draw commerce away from their city's harbor. Pennsylvania's legislature answered the pressure by commissioning the Main Line of Public Works in 1826, a combined system of canals and the inclined-plane Allegheny Portage Railroad erected between 1826 and 1834 to join Philadelphia with Pittsburgh.

Drawing of a canal boat carried on a railcar at the engine house at the head of an incline on the Allegheny Portage Railroad.
Head of Plane No. 6 on the old Allegheny Portage Railroad, with a canal boat carried up the incline on a railcar. Image: George W. Storm, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

In practice, the Main Line of Public Works was slow and awkward. Decades later, travelers and freight moving between Philadelphia and Pittsburgh still had to switch repeatedly between canal boat and railcar, an arrangement that persisted until the Pennsylvania Railroad finally opened one unbroken line in the 1850s.

Two competing applications came before the Pennsylvania legislature in 1846: one for what would become the Pennsylvania Railroad's own charter, the other from the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, which hoped to build its own line to Pittsburgh starting from Cumberland, Maryland. Lawmakers attached the same condition to both: if the Pennsylvania Railroad could not raise sufficient capital and begin enough construction within a year, the B&O's charter would spring into effect in its place and the Pennsylvania Railroad's own charter would be voided.

The Pennsylvania Railroad satisfied that condition, and the governor of Pennsylvania issued its Letters Patent on February 25, 1847. Having confirmed the Pennsylvania Railroad's compliance, the governor voided the B&O's rival claim the following August, clearing the way for the Pennsylvania Railroad to build west from Harrisburg to Pittsburgh.

J. Edgar Thomson and the Railroad's Expansion

To survey and build that line, the Pennsylvania Railroad's directors in 1847 turned to engineer J. Edgar Thomson, luring him away from the Georgia Railroad, where he had risen to chief engineer back in 1834 at just 26 years old. The Pennsylvania Railroad made him its own chief engineer at a yearly salary of $5,000. In a sense, no single figure founded the Pennsylvania Railroad the way company founders are usually imagined: Philadelphia's business community had won the charter, while it fell to Thomson to actually put the railroad on the ground.

Portrait photograph of J. Edgar Thomson.
J. Edgar Thomson, photographed by the Mathew Brady studio about 1860-1870. Image: Mathew Brady Studio, National Portrait Gallery, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Building the line took most of the next decade. In 1848 the company arranged with the Harrisburg, Portsmouth, Mountjoy and Lancaster Railroad to run trains between Harrisburg and Lancaster. Crews finished the segment between Pittsburgh and Johnstown in 1851, and the following year riders could finally travel the full distance from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh without interruption, even though the route crossed track belonging to several different companies in addition to the Pennsylvania Railroad's own rails.

Thomson's standing within the company grew alongside the railroad itself. In 1852 he led a group of directors who removed the sitting board and installed him as president, a position he kept until he died in Philadelphia on May 27, 1874. Five years into his presidency, in 1857, Thomson arranged financing for the Pennsylvania Railroad to buy out the entire Main Line of Public Works from the state, a package that included 278 miles of canal, 117 miles of railroad, and assorted real estate and equipment. That same year the company shut down most of the parallel New Portage Railroad, which had become unnecessary once the Pennsylvania Railroad's own line was running. The canal segment between Johnstown and Pittsburgh went out of service in 1865, and the remaining canal mileage was sold off to the Pennsylvania Canal Company in 1866.

Lawmakers broadened the railroad's charter on March 23, 1853, allowing it for the first time to buy stock in, and guarantee the bonds of, railroads chartered in other states, provided the total stayed within a set share of its own capital stock.

The push toward Chicago came next. The Pennsylvania Railroad, already an investor in the Pittsburgh, Fort Wayne and Chicago Railway, took over its operation under a lease signed on July 1, 1869, which gave the company a direct route all the way into Chicago. Two years later, in 1871, it reached Jersey City, New Jersey, and the New York City area through a lease of the United New Jersey Railroad and Canal Company.

Growth continued after Thomson's death in 1874. In 1890 the railroad gained control of the Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, Chicago and St. Louis Railroad, a line that had itself come together from a patchwork of smaller railroads scattered across Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois. In 1905 it bought the Vandalia Railroad, which extended its reach across the Mississippi River into St. Louis, Missouri. Along the way the company also notched a pair of technical firsts: it was the first American railroad to use steel rails, in 1865, and it introduced air brakes to its operations in 1872.

Horseshoe Curve Across the Alleghenies

West of Altoona, Pennsylvania, the Pennsylvania Railroad's main line sweeps through a dramatic bend known as Horseshoe Curve, engineered to ease the climb trains faced heading west toward the top of the Allegheny Mountains and to retire the slow, labor-intensive Allegheny Portage Railroad it replaced. Construction of the curve got underway in the early 1850s, and the 31.1-mile stretch of line between Altoona and Johnstown that included it opened for regular service on February 15, 1854, a date also given by Altoona's Railroaders Memorial Museum.

A Pennsylvania Railroad freight train led by diesel locomotives rounding Horseshoe Curve below wooded hills.
A Pennsylvania Railroad freight led by an EMD F7 diesel at Horseshoe Curve, on a period postcard. Image: The Camera Shop, Altoona PA, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

All told, the curve bent through 220 degrees, and westbound trains climbed a grade as steep as 1.85 percent across the 12 miles separating Altoona from Gallitzin. Workers cut it entirely by hand, relying on picks, shovels, blasting powder, and teams of mules. Trains pass the actual summit of the Alleghenies just west of the curve, at the Gallitzin Tunnels, which were bored through the mountain alongside the curve itself to carry trains across the divide.

A viewing area built alongside the tracks in 1879 is believed to be the first spot ever built specifically so that people could watch trains go by. As rail traffic grew heavier, the railroad widened the curve with a third track in 1898 and a fourth two years after that. Horseshoe Curve was designated a National Historic Landmark on November 13, 1966, and the American Society of Civil Engineers added its own National Historic Civil Engineering Landmark designation in 2004.

Ownership of the curve passed to Norfolk Southern in 1999, when Conrail's assets were divided between Norfolk Southern and CSX Transportation. The curve has stayed busy ever since as part of Norfolk Southern's Pittsburgh Line: as of 2008 it saw 51 scheduled freight trains pass each day, a count that does not include local switching moves or helper engines, additions that can roughly double the daily total.

The Pennsylvania Railroad by the Numbers

By 1882 the Pennsylvania Railroad had grown into the largest railroad, the largest transportation enterprise, and the largest corporation anywhere in the world, measured by both traffic and revenue.

A restored brown Pennsylvania Railroad steel hopper car, number 33164, on display indoors.
Pennsylvania Railroad GL-class hopper car No. 33164, built by the Pressed Steel Car Company in 1898 and used by the railroad until the late 1930s, photographed in 2016. Image: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The railroad's station list shows how far that network reached: its stops included Baltimore, Chicago, New York City, Newark in New Jersey, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh and Washington, D.C.

Financially, the company paid a dividend at the end of its very first year of operation and kept paying one, without a single interruption, all the way until 1946. Its freight car fleet grew just as dramatically, starting from a first purchase of 75 cars in 1849 and climbing past 87,000 cars by 1896, past 180,000 by 1900, and to 263,039 by 1910, before peaking in 1919 at a reported 282,729 freight cars.

In 1916 the company adopted a new motto: the "Standard Railroad of the World."

A Distinct Identity and One Major Rival

Visually, the Pennsylvania Railroad cultivated a distinct identity. Its corporate symbol was a keystone, the official emblem of the state of Pennsylvania, with the letters "PRR" woven together inside it. Locomotives were finished in a green so dark it read as nearly black, officially called Dark Green Locomotive Enamel but known popularly as Brunswick Green, while passenger cars were painted Tuscan red, a brick-toned shade. One of its signature engineering touches was the square-shouldered Belpaire firebox, a British-style design that few other American locomotive builders ever adopted.

Much of that equipment was built and repaired at Altoona Works, a repair complex whose construction began in 1850 in Altoona, Pennsylvania, a town the railroad itself had planned and established for the purpose. For many years, Altoona Works stood as the largest railroad shop complex anywhere in the world.

A steam locomotive lifted by chains from an overhead crane inside a large railroad shop building.
Hoisting a locomotive in the Pennsylvania Railroad shops at Altoona, one frame of a stereograph from R. A. Bonine's series Views Among the Alleghenies, about 1870-1880. Image: R. A. Bonine, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The railroad also built its reputation through a lineage of named passenger trains. The Pennsylvania Limited started running between New York and Chicago on June 15, 1887; it gave way in 1902 to the Pennsylvania Special, which was itself replaced in 1912 by the Broadway Limited, the most celebrated train the Pennsylvania Railroad ever ran.

The Pennsylvania Railroad's only serious rival was the New York Central Railroad, which handled roughly three-quarters as many ton-miles as the Pennsy did across the territory the two shared. That rivalry traced back to the era's railroad barons: Cornelius Vanderbilt took control of the New York Central Railroad in 1867, then merged it with his own Hudson River Railroad on November 1, 1869, creating the New York Central and Hudson River Railroad.

Electrifying the Main Lines

Electrification arrived gradually. It began in 1910, when the railroad switched on a 650-volt direct-current third-rail system to power its own locomotives, as well as Long Island Rail Road passenger cars, as they rolled into Penn Station in New York City through the tunnels under the Hudson River. The line running from Philadelphia out to Paoli, Pennsylvania, was converted to an overhead electric system by September 12, 1915.

Two coupled dark green Pennsylvania Railroad boxcab electric locomotives, numbers 3936 and 3937, in a museum.
Pennsylvania Railroad DD1 electric locomotives 3936 and 3937, a semi-permanently coupled pair and the only survivors of their class, at the Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania in Strasburg, 2016. Image: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Company president William Wallace Atterbury unveiled a far larger scheme in 1928, calling for electrification of the lines connecting New York, Philadelphia, Washington, and Harrisburg, a plan that bore fruit within a few years: through main-line electric service between New York and Philadelphia, Wilmington, and Paoli began running in January 1933, and on January 28, 1935, the railroad ran a special train to celebrate finishing the electrified line between Washington, D.C., and New York City.

The network reached Harrisburg on January 15, 1938, when the first passenger train to use the newly wired route, the Metropolitan, began running from Philadelphia.

Penn Station: Why It Was Demolished

By the time New York's original Pennsylvania Station came down, its passenger numbers had been falling, a decline that set in with the start of the Jet Age and the buildout of the Interstate Highway System. The railroad had already optioned the station's air rights to developer William Zeckendorf back in 1954, and in 1962 a plan for a new Madison Square Garden above the site, announced by Irving Mitchell Felt, president of Graham-Paige, offered the railroad something in return: a smaller, air-conditioned replacement station built entirely below street level at no cost to the company, plus a 25 percent ownership stake in the new Madison Square Garden complex.

Passengers in the vast vaulted waiting room of the original Pennsylvania Station in New York.
Passengers in the waiting room of the original Pennsylvania Station in New York, 1911, with a statue of PRR president Alexander Johnston Cassatt in a niche on the wall. Image: Library of Congress, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The original station had been designed by the architectural firm McKim, Mead, and White and finished in 1910, giving New York City its very first direct rail connection from the south. Before that, no direct rail line ran from points west of the Hudson River into Manhattan at all; as late as 1896, some 94 million passengers a year still had to travel into Manhattan from railroad terminals across the river in Jersey City. By 1935 the station had served more than a billion passengers in total, and its busiest stretch came during World War II, when more than 100 million people passed through it in 1945 alone. By the early 1960s critics argued the building had been allowed to decay: writing in The New York Times in 1963, architectural critic Ada Louise Huxtable lamented that her own era could neither build a station like it nor even keep one standing.

Demolition of the above-ground station began on October 28, 1963, under Pennsylvania Railroad president Stuart T. Saunders, who would later head Penn Central Transportation. The New York Times described the demolition as a "monumental act of vandalism" against one of the grandest landmarks of its era. Architectural historian Vincent Scully later drew a sharp contrast between the two buildings, suggesting that arriving through the old station had felt like a triumphant entrance into the city itself, while passing through its cramped underground replacement felt furtive and diminished by comparison.

By late 1966 much of the replacement station had been completed below street level.

Penn Central and What Came After

On February 1, 1968, the Pennsylvania Railroad completed its merger with longtime rival New York Central Railroad, forming the Penn Central Transportation Company. The combined company did not last: its board voted to seek bankruptcy protection on June 21, 1970, once the company's finances had collapsed beyond repair. On April 1, 1976, Penn Central's still-viable rail operations were handed over to the newly created, federally owned Consolidated Rail Corporation, or Conrail. Conrail itself was broken apart in 1999, split between Norfolk Southern and CSX Transportation, with Norfolk Southern taking 58 percent of the combined system, including nearly all of what remained of the old Pennsylvania Railroad's own trackage.

A Rails and Rivals map with mountains and rivers
Rails & Rivals, our game.

Rails & Rivals, our game on Steam, is a turn-based railroad strategy board game for 2 to 6 players: each player runs a rail company, lays track across a hex map and carries goods between cities, and the wealthiest company wins. The how to play page has the rules.

Keep reading

Sources